Today, a coalition of technology companies led by Red Hat, announced that we are each adopting a more balanced approach to open source license enforcement. At Red Hat, we believe that license enforcement activities should ordinarily be judged by fairness and whether they ultimately foster greater adoption of open source software and participation in open source development. License enforcement can help to ensure that all companies play by the same rules, but enforcement tactics that are overly aggressive, unfair or unpredictable can discourage users from joining the community.
This means that where enforcement does occur, it should be conducted in a manner that is fair and predictable. In our view, legal proceedings are generally a poor tool for achieving license compliance and can have adverse consequences for the vitality of open source software and licenses. Courts are ill-equipped to understand and appreciate the many nuances associated with open source licenses, including generally accepted community interpretations of license terms. As a result, litigation can lead to unpredictable outcomes that may not be beneficial to collaboration and future license interpretation. For these reasons, we believe that litigation should almost always be avoided.
In addition, we believe that copyright holders should adopt compliance approaches that provide fair opportunities for licensees to correct noncompliance. In today’s announcement, a coalition of technology companies led by Red Hat (including Facebook, Google, and IBM) has each committed to providing additional flexibility to their GPLv2, LGPLv2.1 and LGPLv2 licensees by giving these licensees a period of time to come into compliance before their licenses are terminated.
Red Hat releases much of the software it develops under licenses in the GPL family, reflecting both the choices made by the upstream community projects we depend on and the preferences of our own engineers, among others. When GPL version 3 (GPLv3) was released 10 years ago, one important improvement was its termination policy, which offered users specific opportunities to cure license violations. This GPLv3 change addressed what some, including Red Hat, viewed as a potential for overly-harsh approaches in GPLv2 enforcement, especially in cases of inadvertent noncompliance. The GPLv2 termination approach can be taken by some to provide an undue advantage to copyright holders who use aggressive enforcement tactics. We felt strongly that the large ecosystems of projects using GPLv2 and LGPLv2.x would benefit from adoption of this more balanced approach to termination derived from GPLv3.
Accordingly, Red Hat and the other companies (Facebook, Google, and IBM) are today each individually committing to apply the cure provisions of GPLv3 to our respective copyrighted code that is licensed under GPLv2, LGPLv2.1 and LGPLv2 (except in cases of a defensive response to a legal proceeding).
Innovation takes a village and we note that the Linux kernel project recently adopted this approach in their Linux Kernel Enforcement Statement, and the Free Software Foundation and Software Freedom Conservancy embodied the concept in their Principles of Community-Oriented GPL Enforcement. We also note the prior and significant intellectual contributions of the Software Freedom Law Center and the Free Software Foundation in their pioneering work on GPLv3 that laid the foundation for this approach.
We encourage other copyright holders to follow our collective lead and hope that these efforts will promote the growth of the large ecosystems of open source projects that use and depend on our collective software contributions.
Red Hat’s commitment can be found here.
À propos de l'auteur
Red Hat is the world’s leading provider of enterprise open source software solutions, using a community-powered approach to deliver reliable and high-performing Linux, hybrid cloud, container, and Kubernetes technologies.
Red Hat helps customers integrate new and existing IT applications, develop cloud-native applications, standardize on our industry-leading operating system, and automate, secure, and manage complex environments. Award-winning support, training, and consulting services make Red Hat a trusted adviser to the Fortune 500. As a strategic partner to cloud providers, system integrators, application vendors, customers, and open source communities, Red Hat can help organizations prepare for the digital future.
Contenu similaire
Parcourir par canal
Automatisation
Les dernières nouveautés en matière d'automatisation informatique pour les technologies, les équipes et les environnements
Intelligence artificielle
Actualité sur les plateformes qui permettent aux clients d'exécuter des charges de travail d'IA sur tout type d'environnement
Cloud hybride ouvert
Découvrez comment créer un avenir flexible grâce au cloud hybride
Sécurité
Les dernières actualités sur la façon dont nous réduisons les risques dans tous les environnements et technologies
Edge computing
Actualité sur les plateformes qui simplifient les opérations en périphérie
Infrastructure
Les dernières nouveautés sur la plateforme Linux d'entreprise leader au monde
Applications
À l’intérieur de nos solutions aux défis d’application les plus difficiles
Programmes originaux
Histoires passionnantes de créateurs et de leaders de technologies d'entreprise
Produits
- Red Hat Enterprise Linux
- Red Hat OpenShift
- Red Hat Ansible Automation Platform
- Services cloud
- Voir tous les produits
Outils
- Formation et certification
- Mon compte
- Assistance client
- Ressources développeurs
- Rechercher un partenaire
- Red Hat Ecosystem Catalog
- Calculateur de valeur Red Hat
- Documentation
Essayer, acheter et vendre
Communication
- Contacter le service commercial
- Contactez notre service clientèle
- Contacter le service de formation
- Réseaux sociaux
À propos de Red Hat
Premier éditeur mondial de solutions Open Source pour les entreprises, nous fournissons des technologies Linux, cloud, de conteneurs et Kubernetes. Nous proposons des solutions stables qui aident les entreprises à jongler avec les divers environnements et plateformes, du cœur du datacenter à la périphérie du réseau.
Sélectionner une langue
Red Hat legal and privacy links
- À propos de Red Hat
- Carrières
- Événements
- Bureaux
- Contacter Red Hat
- Lire le blog Red Hat
- Diversité, équité et inclusion
- Cool Stuff Store
- Red Hat Summit