Today Red Hat took its efforts to confront the problem of software patents to new ground by filing a brief with the European Patent Office. The brief explains that software patents hinder software innovation, and that there is a sound legal basis not to expand availability of such patents in Europe.
Last year, Red Hat addressed the software patent problem in the U.S. case of In re Bilski, where the court of appeals handed down a new – and more FOSS-friendly - test for determining whether an invention is patentable. In the new brief, we explain how Bilski may ultimately be interpreted to remedy the problem of software patents.
The proceeding of the European Patent Office is called a referral to the Enlarged Board of Appeal, which addresses important general issues of patent law under the European Patent Convention, or EPC. In the current referral, the Enlarged Board is addressing the exclusion set forth in in the EPC for computer programs. Prior decisions have applied the law inconsistently, so that the exclusion for computer programs has been “interpreted” to allow thousands of software patents. The Enlarged Board is charged with clarifying this law, and could either limit the availability of software patents or expand it.
As explained in our brief, there are strong practical and legal arguments against software patents. It is increasingly accepted as settled by scholars that software patents impose enormous economic costs, including costs of litigation, that are not justified. All software developers face a risk that code they created without reference to a patent could nevertheless someday be argued to infringe patents unknown to them. With hundreds of thousands of software patents in the U.S., there is no practical way for anyone, including giant software companies, to rule out this possibility.
The numbers of software patents in Europe is smaller, and there’s a straightforward legal argument based on the language of the EPC that the number should be zero. Our brief argues that the case law that limiting the computer program exclusion based on such vague concepts as a “technical effect” should be set aside, and the exclusion should be applied according to its plain language.
In spite of the clear risks that the patent system poses, not only to FOSS but also to proprietary software, there are still strong supporters of software patents. There are occasional examples of software patents that result in large profits for the patent holders, but they are few. In this respect, the patent system is very like the lottery, where out of many players, a very small number win big. Most lottery players, and most patent players, start with dreams of vast riches, and only end up the poorer. Remarkably, despite the economic reality of consistent losses, some will not give up the game.
Whatever the evolutionary explanation for such behavior, it’s clear from the briefs submitted to the Enlarged Board that Red Hat’s analysis of problems of software patent is not the majority view. But the Bilski decision is a reminder that positive legal change is possible. As our brief today shows, we’re continuing to fight for such change.
Sobre el autor
Navegar por canal
Automatización
Las últimas novedades en la automatización de la TI para los equipos, la tecnología y los entornos
Inteligencia artificial
Descubra las actualizaciones en las plataformas que permiten a los clientes ejecutar cargas de trabajo de inteligecia artificial en cualquier lugar
Nube híbrida abierta
Vea como construimos un futuro flexible con la nube híbrida
Seguridad
Vea las últimas novedades sobre cómo reducimos los riesgos en entornos y tecnologías
Edge computing
Conozca las actualizaciones en las plataformas que simplifican las operaciones en el edge
Infraestructura
Vea las últimas novedades sobre la plataforma Linux empresarial líder en el mundo
Aplicaciones
Conozca nuestras soluciones para abordar los desafíos más complejos de las aplicaciones
Programas originales
Vea historias divertidas de creadores y líderes en tecnología empresarial
Productos
- Red Hat Enterprise Linux
- Red Hat OpenShift
- Red Hat Ansible Automation Platform
- Servicios de nube
- Ver todos los productos
Herramientas
- Training y Certificación
- Mi cuenta
- Soporte al cliente
- Recursos para desarrolladores
- Busque un partner
- Red Hat Ecosystem Catalog
- Calculador de valor Red Hat
- Documentación
Realice pruebas, compras y ventas
Comunicarse
- Comuníquese con la oficina de ventas
- Comuníquese con el servicio al cliente
- Comuníquese con Red Hat Training
- Redes sociales
Acerca de Red Hat
Somos el proveedor líder a nivel mundial de soluciones empresariales de código abierto, incluyendo Linux, cloud, contenedores y Kubernetes. Ofrecemos soluciones reforzadas, las cuales permiten que las empresas trabajen en distintas plataformas y entornos con facilidad, desde el centro de datos principal hasta el extremo de la red.
Seleccionar idioma
Red Hat legal and privacy links
- Acerca de Red Hat
- Oportunidades de empleo
- Eventos
- Sedes
- Póngase en contacto con Red Hat
- Blog de Red Hat
- Diversidad, igualdad e inclusión
- Cool Stuff Store
- Red Hat Summit